Changing the heat and hot water supplier during martial law cannot be a basis for raising tariffs for the population. Consumers must be protected from additional costs regardless of which company provides the services and who sets their cost.

This legal position was formulated by the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court, as reported by the court's press service on November 16.

The basis for consideration was a lawsuit by a resident of Kremenchuk against the company "Poltava teploenergo". After the destruction of equipment of the Kremenchuk CHP as a result of Russian missile strikes, the heat and hot water supplier in the city changed.

From November 2022, the new company began charging the consumer according to tariffs higher than those that applied to him as of February 24, 2022.

The man filed a lawsuit demanding a recalculation. The court of first instance rejected him, but the appellate court sided with the consumer and ordered the company to review charges for the heating seasons 2022-2023 and 2023-2024, as well as the interheating period of 2023.

"Poltava teploenergo" appealed this decision. The company insisted that it applied tariffs approved by the Poltava Regional Council and was not the legal successor of the previous supplier - "Kremenchuk CHP".

The Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court rejected these arguments and upheld the appellate court's decision unchanged.

The court explained that the ban on raising tariffs for heat and hot water provided by Law No. 2479-IX, in the version in force at the time of the dispute, is aimed at protecting consumers, not individual enterprises.

Therefore, a change in supplier or lack of authority to independently set tariffs does not give grounds to increase the fee compared to what a specific consumer paid before February 24, 2022.

The Supreme Court also emphasized that residents cannot independently choose a centralized heat supply provider. Accordingly, they should not bear additional costs due to decisions of authorities or a change in the company servicing their buildings.

At the same time, the law provides for compensation to suppliers of the difference in tariffs from the state budget. Therefore, the corresponding financial burden cannot be automatically shifted to the population.

The decision is significant not only for the specific dispute in Kremenchuk. The Grand Chamber eliminated discrepancies in previous case law and departed from the opposite conclusion of the Commercial Court of Cassation formulated in September 2024.

At the same time, the decision does not mean an automatic recalculation of utility payments for all consumers in Ukraine. The decision directly concerns the plaintiff in the case, but the formulated legal conclusion must be taken into account by courts when considering similar disputes.

If after a change in supplier a consumer is charged according to higher tariffs, he can apply to the company with a demand to check the charges and conduct a recalculation. In case of refusal, the legality of the applied tariffs can be challenged in court taking into account the circumstances of a specific case.

The Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court adopted the resolution on September 9, 2026 in case No. 524/10323/24. The official explanation of the legal position was published on November 16.

Based on materials: Supreme Court, resolution in case No. 524/10323/24