In France, the American company Apple will face trial on charges of impeding the repair of iPhones outside authorized service centers. The court hearing is scheduled for June 2027. The company is suspected of using software restrictions that could complicate component replacement and increase costs for smartphone owners.
The French organization Halte à l'obsolescence programmée (HOP), which initiated the case, reported this on November 17. Details are also provided by Le Monde.
The decision to send the case to court was made by the Paris prosecutor's office after an investigation that began with a complaint from HOP in December 2022. The first preparatory hearing is scheduled for February 25, 2027, and the substantive hearing is supposed to take place in June.
At the center of the claims is serialization technology, by which Apple programmatically links individual smartphone components to a specific device. After parts are replaced, the system checks their compatibility and may restrict certain functions if the repair did not undergo the manufacturer's verification procedure.
According to HOP, such mechanisms complicated the work of independent repair shops. Restrictions could occur even after installing original Apple parts taken from another smartphone.
In particular, this concerns the replacement of displays, batteries, and cameras. In some cases, users could lose access to certain device functions or receive notifications about an unknown component.
As Numerama writes, the case covers 24 iPhone models and practices applied from November 2021 to July 2024.
According to the rights organization, the software restrictions could force owners to turn to authorized service centers, where repairs are often more expensive, or to give up repairing an old device in favor of a new one.
Since 2021, France has had a legislative ban on the use of technologies, including software, aimed at hindering the repair or restoration of equipment outside the manufacturer's official service networks.
Apple categorically denies the accusations. The company states that it designs durable devices and continues to improve their repairability.
However, in recent years the manufacturer has already changed some restrictions. Apple has expanded access to original spare parts and allowed independent workshops to verify certain repair operations. Since 2024, some software blocks after component replacement have also been lifted.
This is not Apple's first dispute with French regulators over the lifespan of smartphones. In 2020, the company agreed to pay a fine of 25 million euros for insufficiently informing users about the possible slowdown of older iPhones after software updates.
The current case concerns different claims - the right of owners to repair devices and use independent repair shops. The court must provide a final legal assessment of Apple's practices.