American negotiators for the first time asked Ukraine whether it would agree to withdraw its troops from the Kyiv-controlled part of Donbas in exchange for NATO membership. President Volodymyr Zelenskyy stated that the Ukrainian side did not agree to territorial concessions, but is ready to discuss a specific package of security guarantees with the participation of the US and European allies.

Bloomberg reports this, analyzing a new stage of negotiations on ending the war. Zelenskyy himself spoke about the relevant question from the American side during a meeting with journalists on November 13.

According to the president, Washington previously discussed the possibility of territorial concessions in exchange for security guarantees, but now for the first time directly linked the issue of Ukraine's withdrawal from Donbas with possible NATO membership. Zelenskyy emphasized that Ukraine does not intend to give up its territories, and there is still no specific agreed proposal from partners.

Kyiv is discussing with partners a comprehensive security package consisting of three components: guarantees from NATO and the European Union, maintaining a strong Ukrainian army with designated funding, and a post-war recovery plan with clearly established sources of funds. Zelenskyy stressed that only with concrete commitments from the US and other allies can the proposed conditions be substantively considered.

The most difficult issue remains the content of future guarantees. Ukraine considers a minimum necessary mechanism for protection based on Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty, which provides for collective defense of allies. At the same time, American representatives, according to Zelenskyy, talk about guarantees similar to Articles 4 and 5 of NATO, but do not provide for the deployment of US military personnel on Ukrainian territory.

The president explained that Washington compares the possible format with bilateral security agreements that the United States has with Israel and some Middle Eastern countries. However, Kyiv has not yet received sufficiently concrete information about what obligations partners will assume and how they will act in the event of new Russian aggression. Therefore, guarantees modeled on NATO should not be equated with Ukraine's actual membership in the Alliance.

Zelenskyy stated that if a full security package is confirmed by the American side and other allies, he will turn to Ukrainian society to ascertain its position on the proposed conditions. At the same time, the president emphasized that even possible agreements cannot provide for legal recognition of the occupied Ukrainian territories as Russian.

Moscow's position remains a significant obstacle to such a scenario. According to Bloomberg, during negotiations with US special representatives Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, Vladimir Putin opposed the presence of foreign troops in Ukraine. Russia also seeks to discuss broader restrictions on NATO's military presence in Eastern Europe, which European allies object to.

Washington seeks to combine negotiations on territorial issues with agreements on post-war security for Ukraine and Europe. However, there is currently neither an agreed mechanism for Ukraine's NATO accession nor a decision to transfer the Kyiv-controlled part of Donbas to Russia. The question from American negotiators remains one of the options being discussed by the parties, not a achieved peace agreement.

Based on materials from: Bloomberg, LB.ua