President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelenskyy said that Kyiv has not yet received a clear explanation of the mechanism of security guarantees that the United States proposes to provide by analogy with Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty. The main questions concern the presence of foreign military and the actions of allies in the event of a repeated attack by Russia.
The head of state said this during a conversation with journalists. Relevant statements were also cited by Ukrainian media on November 14.
According to Zelenskyy, Ukraine insists on effective guarantees that will prevent new Russian aggression after the end of the war. The American side proposes to consider bilateral commitments comparable to NATO's collective defense mechanisms.
However, when asked about the possible presence of American military personnel on the territory of Ukraine, Kyiv received a negative answer. This raised additional questions regarding the practical content of the proposed guarantees.
"So then I ask: what does 'similar to Article 5' mean and what does 'similar to NATO' mean? They say: these are bilateral security guarantees. Similar to the ones that Israel has," — Zelenskyy said.
The president also cited the example of individual Middle Eastern countries that have defense arrangements with the US. Some of them host American military bases, aviation, and air defense systems. In the event of a threat, this infrastructure can be used to protect the territory of the host state.
Zelenskyy emphasized that Ukraine needs to understand exactly what obligations the partners will assume, what the procedure for their implementation will be, and whether direct military intervention by allies will follow in the event of a new Russian attack.
On November 19, the issue of security guarantees was again discussed at a meeting of the "coalition of the willing" in Berlin. In the joint statement adopted following the meeting, the leaders of Germany, France, the United Kingdom, and Ukraine confirmed the need for legally binding guarantees after the ceasefire comes into effect.
Among the possible mechanisms named are long-term military and financial support for the Ukrainian army, international control over compliance with the truce under the leadership of the United States, as well as multinational forces under European command with American support.
The document provides for the possibility of adopting legally binding measures to restore peace and security in the event of a new armed attack by Russia. However, the specific actions of the guarantor states must be determined taking into account their national procedures.
On the same day, American negotiator Jared Kushner stated that Washington has managed to make progress in discussing guarantees modeled on Article 5 of NATO. In his assessment, the Russian side is ready to consider such a concept.
Kushner added that US President Donald Trump is open to providing such guarantees, but they must be in America's interests and become part of a broader agreement.
At the moment, the final mechanism for protecting Ukraine has not been approved. In particular, the obligations of individual countries, the conditions for the possible deployment of foreign military, and the procedure for responding to repeated Russian aggression have not been determined.